Hi Prof Foster,
I wanted to let you know that I haven't been able to submit my paper because I cannot access turnitin.com. I emailed you at the "bmcc" email address for this and another situation, is this the correct address? Please advise. Thank you.
Civil Disobedience:
This week is interesting because reading two of the greatest philosophers ever and seeing the contrast between their opinions on civil disobedience is profound. I especially would like to know where Socrates and Dr. King would stand as far as the actions of the Zuccotti park protesters. Would Dr. king say they have a right to protest the fact that they do not have jobs or would he say that it would be better if we boycotted their businesses. It would be interesting to see how Dr. King would view the residents the live in the neighborhood of the park whom have somewhat demonized the protesters for their nuisance like behavior. Would he say that they are more evil because they are the bystanders?
I was really shocked to read that Socrates would not escape from jail. I am definitely down for the cause and the fight, but death is pretty much permanent and I cannot understand how one can be certain that his or her death will be for the greater good. I would like to think that I would have chosen exile if I were Socrates, especially given the fact that he has kids.
Socrates' situation was very different to MLKs, and the social/cultural differences help to explain their different understanding of CD. I can see why you find Socrates' position difficult to make sense of.
ReplyDelete